A History of the Surrealism collection at the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art

It comes as a surprise to some of our visitors to find that the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art owns a world-class collection of surrealist art. Moreover, our collection of rare illustrated books, catalogues, manuscripts and journals by surrealist artists is one of the best in the world. This is all thanks to the acquisition of part of the Roland Penrose Collection and Archive, and to the Gabrielle Keiller bequest of 1995.

The surrealist movement was launched in Paris in 1924 but it was not until 1936 that the British responded by creating their own surrealist group and staging their own surrealist exhibition. If it is true that British artists were reluctant to join the movement, it is also the case that British museums and galleries proved slow in joining in. The first broadly surrealist painting to enter a public collection in Britain was probably Giorgio de Chirico’s triptych The Philosopher of 1928, which was given to the Whitworth Art Gallery in Manchester in 1931. And it was not until 1941 that the Tate Gallery in London acquired its first example of continental Surrealism, Max Ernst’s The Entire City.

The Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art opened in Edinburgh in 1960 and the first painting by a surrealist artist to enter the collection was an untypical late work by André Masson, River in Winter, bought in 1967. More impressive, however, was Alberto Giacometti’s Woman with her Throat Cut which was purchased in 1970, with further additions by René Magritte, Joan Miró and Ernst. Through one-off acquisitions such as these, the Gallery assembled a reasonably good collection of surrealist art.

  • Femme égorgée [Woman with her Throat Cut] Femme √©gorg√©e [Woman with her Throat Cut], by Alberto Giacometti
  • Le Drapeau noir [The Black Flag] Le Drapeau noir [The Black Flag], by Ren√© Magritte
  • Peinture [Painting] Peinture [Painting], by Joan Mir√≥

Yet it was thanks to Roland Penrose that the collection first grew dramatically. Whilst studying at Cambridge University, Penrose became interested in modern art and in the autumn of 1922 he moved to Paris. By the mid-1920s Surrealism had caught his eye and in 1926 he met Ernst and through him other members of the surrealist group. Following a chance encounter with David Gascoyne, who was researching a book on Surrealism in Paris in 1935, Penrose became determined that they must galvanise support in Britain and organise a major exhibition. The International Surrealist Exhibition, held in London in 1936, was a triumph and succeeded in cementing the movement in Britain.

Following the death of his mother in 1930 and his father in 1932, Penrose had come into his inheritance. His new-found wealth had already enabled him to help finance Ernst’s great collage novel, Une Semaine de bonté, and it also meant that he was in the perfect position to buy the work of his friends. His first major purchase was Ernst’s jungle landscape, La Joie de Vivre, acquired in 1935 before it was even finished.

  • Une Semaine de Bonté... où les Sept Élements Capitaux. Roman [A Week of Kindness... or The Seven Capital Elements. Novel] Une Semaine de Bont√©... o√Ļ les Sept √Člements Capitaux. Roman [A Week of Kindness... or The Seven Capital Elements. Novel], by Max Ernst
  • Untitled (Unpublished collage for 'Une Semaine de Bonté') Untitled (Unpublished collage for 'Une Semaine de Bont√©'), by Max Ernst
  • La Joie de vivre [The Joy of Life] La Joie de vivre [The Joy of Life], by Max Ernst

By early 1937 Penrose owned a small but choice group of surrealist works. In July of that year he transformed his collection when he acquired a set of works belonging to the Belgian collector and businessman Ren√© Gaff√©. Yet Penrose‚Äôs greatest coup as a collector came in August 1938 when he bought more than 100 surrealist and cubist works from his friend Paul √Čluard. Suddenly, Penrose had a collection of museum importance hanging on the walls of his London home.

In around 1958 Penrose met Douglas Hall, then Deputy Director of Manchester City Art Galleries. Hall was appointed the first Keeper of the Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art in November 1961, and a few months later he took the opportunity to renew his contact with Penrose. In 1981 Penrose attempted to sell a fine Cubist painting by Picasso, Guitar, Gas-Jet and Bottle, but since it failed to sell, it was instead offered to the Gallery, and was bought in 1982. This was the first acquisition made from the Penrose Collection.

Richard Calvocoressi, who took over from Douglas Hall as Keeper in 1987, concentrated the majority of available funds in this area, conscious that while the purchases might stretch the budget, this was the last opportunity to acquire such masterpieces. In 1991, Calvocoressi and Antony Penrose, Roland‚Äôs son, together worked out an acquisition strategy that was to bring the Gallery of Modern Art many benefits over the next decade. Mir√≥‚Äôs Maternity was purchased in 1991 and Henry Moore‚Äôs ‚ÄėHelmet‚Äô was bought the following year. In 1994 the gallery acquired Roland Penrose‚Äôs magnificent library and archive, which included a large number of rare artist books, and a wealth of correspondence.

  • Guitare, bec à gaz, flacon [Guitar, Gas-jet and Bottle] Guitare, bec √† gaz, flacon [Guitar, Gas-jet and Bottle], by Pablo Picasso
  • Maternité [Maternity] Maternit√© [Maternity], by Joan Mir√≥
  • The Helmet The Helmet, by Henry Moore

When Britain’s first National Lottery was launched late in 1994, the Gallery of Modern Art was an early beneficiary of its grant-giving arm, the Heritage Lottery Fund. A grant of £3 million, awarded in 1995, allowed the Gallery to buy a collection of twenty-six paintings and drawings from the Penrose Collection. Just a few months after these acquisitions the gallery received the most important gift in its history, the collection of Gabrielle Keiller.

Although she never lived in Scotland, Keiller was born north of the border. After the Second World War, she sold her share of the family’s land in Texas and the funds allowed her to indulge her passion for collecting. In 1951 she married Alexander Keiller who also had a passion for the bizarre, collecting books on witchcraft and demonology. Twenty years older than Gabrielle, he died in 1955; however, his interest in the unusual seemed to rub off on her. In 1960 Gabrielle Keiller went on a trip to Italy, where she met Peggy Guggenheim in Venice. Guggenheim’s collection of surrealist art proved an important turning point in Keiller’s life, as too did her visit to the British Pavilion at the Venice Biennale, where she saw work by the sculptor Eduardo Paolozzi. From that moment on her energies were devoted to building a collection of Surrealism and the work of Paolozzi. She was also passionate about the literary aspect of the movement, putting together a magnificent library and archive, full of rare books and manuscripts.

Douglas Hall visited Keiller in January 1976 and on his returned to Edinburgh he wrote, thanking her for her welcome, and eloquently implying, without actually stating it, that her collection would receive an equally warm welcome if ever it found its way to Edinburgh. When Richard Calvocoressi became keeper in 1987 he revived the Gallery of Modern Art’s relationship with her, leading to the exhibition of her collection in 1988. As a result of this, and in line with Keiller’s desire to share her collection with others, she decided to bequeath her collection to the Gallery. The Scottish National Gallery of Modern Art’s collection thus grew beyond recognition in the space of a few years.

  • Fish Circus Fish Circus, by Eileen Agar
  • Coin de chasteté [Wedge of Chastity] Coin de chastet√© [Wedge of Chastity], by Marcel Duchamp
  • Untitled (Suite of Collages) Untitled (Suite of Collages), by Georges Hugnet
  • Le Miroir magique [The Magic Mirror] Le Miroir magique [The Magic Mirror], by Ren√© Magritte
  • Le Signal de l'angoisse [The Signal of Anguish] Le Signal de l'angoisse [The Signal of Anguish], by Salvador Dal√≠